ETHICAL ISSUES IN WORK MENTAL HEALTH PROGRAMS

Swedish researchers have examined work-directed cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) interventions and team-based support programs involving nearly 3,000 workers suffering from depression, anxiety, adjustment disorders, or ‘reactions to severe stress’.

The researchers found that such programs help workers with mental disorders return to work and improve outcomes after a year compared to standard care. However, they caution that employers should be aware of the ethical considerations arising from their use, and that the findings should be cautiously interpreted due to a lack of well-designed studies.

The review identified several ethical issues:

Guilt and Shame: Interventions might increase feelings of guilt and shame in workers by focusing on their mental health rather than workplace problems and systems issues.

Loss of Autonomy: Increased cooperation between workers, employers, and healthcare or insurer representatives can undermine workers' autonomy and control over their personal information.

Informed Decisions: Workers' mental disorder symptoms might hinder their ability to make informed and autonomous decisions.

Voluntary Participation: Ethical questions arise about whether workers' participation is truly voluntary and if they can control intervention elements.

Privacy Concerns: Workers may struggle to withhold personal and health-related information from their employers during support meetings.

Common Goal vs. Ethical Costs: While the goal of these interventions is to reintegrate employees back to work, they come with ethical costs for workers and stakeholders.

Unions and HSRs should be mindful of such considerations when be consulted regarding any proposals to introduce work-directed interventions.

Review the study in full here.

Share Tweet

RELATED

WOMEN’S RIGHTS AT WORK FESTIVAL
The Women's Rights At Work Festival is kicking off next month and we have a packed program. Come together to rally, celebrate wins, get involved in campaigns, learn about your new rights...
Read More
40% OF EMPLOYERS UNAWARE OF POSITIVE DUTY TO PREVENT HARASSMENT
Workplace sexual harassment is a serious and persistent problem directly impacting one in three employees. As well as causing significant personal harm, it costs the economy more than $3.8billion per year. Evidence...
Read More
THE MENTAL HEALTH IMPACT OF PRECARIOUS EMPLOYMENT
Recent research confirms the negative effects of precarious employment on employee’s mental health. Research using fifteen years of data shows that hours worked, employment status and perceptions of job security and control...
Read More