WORKER'S SELF-DEFENSE RULING OVERTURNED

A worker who had previously been cleared of misconduct for a scuffle with a member of the public may now face consequences as a commission full bench has overturned the decision.

The NSW train driver successfully contested his dismissal for violating customer violence policies by getting into a fight with a member of the public at Bankstown Railway Station in 2022.

During the altercation, the worker attempted multiple times to move past the man who had tried to trip him. However, they became entangled, leading the worker to kick and push the man in self-defense.

The initial commission ruling had found that NSW Trains failed to prove that the worker was not acting in self-defense, thus deeming the dismissal unjust. Subsequently, the full bench determined that the self-defense test was incorrectly applied in the worker's case.

NSW Trains argued that the worker should bear the burden of proof when claiming self-defense, and the bench agreed, stating that the worker must provide evidence it was self-defense.

The matter will be reheard, potentially impacting how allegations of self-defense in response to misconduct are handled in the future, though the bench has offered the parties the option of conciliation, prior to any rehearing.

NSW Trains T/A NSW Trainlink v Wael Al-Buseri [2023] FWCFB 165 (21 September 2023)

Share Tweet

RELATED

ADVERSE WORK CONDITIONS A RISK FACTOR IN ADJUSTMENT TO PARENTHOOD
A significant proportion of the global workforce consists of parents – in 2023 34% of adults aged 25 to 54 had a least one child under the age of six. The number...
Read More
EMPLOYEE PROSECUTED FOR INJURING LABOUR HIRE WORKER
An employee of Delta Recycling Pty Ltd who was directly supervising a labour hire worker has been prosecuted for their actions that contributed to the labour hire worker sustaining a serious broken...
Read More
$6OK FINE FOR COMPANY THAT IGNORED WARNINGS BEFORE WORKER FELL
Iron Up Australia Pty. Ltd., a construction company that performs carpentry and framing work, has been convicted and fined $60,000 after a contractor was seriously injured in a fall.
Read More