UNFAIR DISMISSAL CLAIM DENIED: ‘MALIGNANT RESENTMENT’ CITED

BHP Operations Services has successfully defended an unfair dismissal claim by an employee absent from work since March 2022.

The company had commissioned an independent medical examination (IME) which determined that the worker suffered from a chronic adjustment disorder and was unable to return to her position due to her feelings of ‘malignant resentment’ toward the employer.

The IME concluded that her anxiety and mistrust of the employer would worsen her condition if she returned to work.

The worker argued that the IME unfairly relied on her reports about a toxic work culture and workplace complaints instead of assessing her ability to perform her job tasks. She claimed that with the right support, she could perform her duties effectively. She also mentioned instances of bullying and harassment from her supervisor and a threatening incident involving a colleague when discussing mandatory COVID vaccinations.

BHP stated it terminated her employment out of concern for health and safety risks and their belief she couldn't safely perform her role.

The Fair Work Commission agreed, concluding the IME clearly indicated the worker's inability to return to her former role due to her mental state, noting the IME provided a clear view the worker couldn't return to her role.

As a result, the workers claim of unfair dismissal was dismissed.

The case illustrates that mistrust or resentment towards the employer, no matter how justified, can be used as a reason for dismissal. Maintaining a professional demeanor and demonstrating a commitment to resolving the situation, when possible, can be crucial.

Source: OHS Alert, 15 August

Share Tweet

RELATED

VISA SCHEME REPORT - MEAT PROCESSOR WORKERS FACE UNSAFE CONDITIONS
A report from RMIT on the experiences of meat processing workers in Australia under the PALM (Pacific Australian Labour Mobility) scheme shows that the $75B industry is thriving “on the backs of...
Read More
SUPAGAS $50K FINE FOR GAS CYLINDER TRUCK ROLLOVER
Supagas Pty Ltd, a national gas distributer, has been fined $50,000 after one of their gas cylinder delivery trucks lost a wheel and crashed on a major Melbourne tollway in 2019. The...
Read More
$270K FINE FOR CONSTRUCTION FALL FATALITY
Minoan Constructions Pty Ltd has been fined $270,000 after a member of their own family fell to his death on their worksite in 2022. The 69-year-old man was helping in the family-operated...
Read More